Got silt? Oak woodland to become dirt pile.

December 4, 2010 § 6 Comments

A perennial management problem for our channelized, dammed river system is sediment. Natural rivers use sediment to shape and reshape their channels and floodplains – in fact the channel dimensions reflect the most efficient way for it to move that sediment.

Not so in our engineered systems. Dams trap sediment, while over-wide channels cause it to drop out, foster colonies of vegetation: both reduce flood capacity. So as long as we have people living in floodways and an engineered system, there will be jobs-for-life for the guys who truck out dirt.
What’s bewildering is where to put all this sediment. Again, nature distributes it along the floodplain, and ultimately the finest material makes it to coastal wetlands and the beaches. Not so, today. If the County has its way, it will raze an 11-acre century-old oak woodland in Arcadia to make space for dirt piles.

Funny, ’cause when I look at a map of the Arcadia-Monrovia area, near the imperiled oak grove, I see a lot of very big holes in the ground. (if any aren’t used for water recharge, what’s the big? Store it there, at least until we can get a grip on better ways to manage this stuff) Or consider the salinization problem with soil in our nearby Central Valley ag lands – wouldn’t good soil be a resource that increases our food security?

The fact is, local government is acting like parking lots have more intrinsic value than these oak woodlands, described as being in a canyon – will a stream also be impacted?

Equally disappointing, however, is that this proposal went through a 2-year environmental review process – and made it through unscathed. As much as I appreciate that we even have a public process and environmental protections, clearly they don’t go far enough to ensure that the public actually knows what’s on the table. The news didn’t cover this when it was a proposal, but waited til it was a crisis. And environmental regulations, as I feel I drone on and on about, don’t necessarily protect natural resources so much as lay out a process for evaluating and “mitigating” the loss of natural resources. But how do you mitigate time? It took one century for these trees to grow to the state that we appreciate them today. Streams flow for millenia and then are abruptly filled. And how can you agree that the mitigation will provide the same quality of habitat when 11 acres is being cleared on one site and the mitigation project will take place on acreage half that size with three times the number of trees? How will overcrowding those trees be an effective way to ensure no net loss?

You can let your Supervisor know how you feel about this:

D1: Gloria Molina:
SD2: Mark Ridley-Thomas:
SD3: Zev Yaroslavsky:
SD4:For Don Knabe: Aaron Nevarez handles enviro/public works
SD5: Mike Antonovich:

News Sources:

San Gabriel Valley Tribune: Last ditch effort to save pristine native woodland from clearance

Los Angeles Times: Century-old oaks in the San Gabriel Mountains may make way — for silt –


Tagged: , , , , , ,

§ 6 Responses to Got silt? Oak woodland to become dirt pile.

  • I agree with you on this topic, Jessica. Thank you for posting on it. The many-years old trees are only a part of the ecosystem which will be lost if this bureaucratic management decision goes forward. More ecological wisdom is needed in government.

  • Sean says:

    The City of LA has a Native Tree Protection Ordinance –
    The County could learn a bit from them.

  • Cindy says:

    Maybe LA County could learn a few things from San Bernardino, this is from their website:

    Oak woodlands provide habitat for more than 300 species of wildlife, moderate temperature extremes, reduce soil erosion and sustain water quality. Moreover, oak woodlands facilitate nutrient cycling and provide forage for numerous wildlife species. The wildlife that surrounds the trees depends on them for many reasons, such as, protection for nesting, shelter, food, and shade. However, according to the Oaks 2040 survey, it estimates that 750,000 acres of California oak woodlands will be seriously threatened by 2040 as a burgeoning state population makes ever more use of the wild land in California.

    In 2001, the California State Legislature approved the California Oak Woodlands Conservation Act. The Act acknowledges the monetary and ecological value of oak woodlands and resulted in the creation of the California Oak Woodlands Conservation Program that provides $10 million dollars in grants for public and private oak woodland conservation efforts.

    Despite these efforts, the State continues to lose oak woodlands to development, firewood harvesting and agricultural conversions. For projects affecting oak woodlands within the County of San Bernardino, the County has established a special permitting process that provides special consideration to California oak woodlands.

  • charlie says:

    Yeah, I agree. Mitigation is being so abused here, mitigation of oak woodland doesn’t even make sense. dumb…

  • Cindy says:

    I found a facebook group for this cause, if you are on facebook do a search for “Save the Arcadia Woodlands” and click join next to the search results.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

What’s this?

You are currently reading Got silt? Oak woodland to become dirt pile. at L.A. Creek Freak.


%d bloggers like this: